A televised clash over health advice has forced Prime Minister Scott Morrison to reprimand Liberal backbencher Craig Kelly but has sparked doubts about whether the move will stop the MP airing his disputed claims about COVID-19.
The government is counting on a public assurance from Mr Kelly to support the mammoth vaccination rollout due to start within weeks, assuming he will curb his contested posts on Facebook about alternative treatments.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison said his views “do not align” with those of Liberal backbencher Craig Kelly.Credit:Dominic Lorrimer/Alex Ellinghausen
Labor welcomed the moves but criticised Mr Morrison for being too slow to bring any pressure to bear on Mr Kelly, whose posts have been blamed for undermining public support in official health advice.
Mr Morrison made a statement to Parliament after question time on Wednesday to praise the official advice from Chief Medical Officer Paul Kelly and rebuke Mr Kelly, who holds the seat of Hughes in southern Sydney.
“It is true that the views expressed by the Member for Hughes do not align with my views, or the views of the advice that has been provided to me by the Chief Medical Officer,” Mr Morrison said.
“Vaccination is critical. It is our primary responsibility this year, as we continue to respond to the pandemic.”
The statement came after Labor challenged Mr Morrison to condemn Mr Kelly and Labor frontbencher Tanya Plibersek clashed with the Liberal backbencher in a televised argument that intensified political pressure on the Prime Minister.
Labor leader Anthony Albanese told Parliament he welcomed the “belated” statement from Mr Morrison to distance himself from Mr Kelly.
But when Mr Albanese described Mr Kelly’s comments as “dangerous” the Liberal MP interjected by asking “which ones?” – a sign he would continue the dispute over whether his remarks were right or wrong.
Mr Morrison made no personal criticism of Mr Kelly and did not suggest a sanction against him.
Mr Kelly did not repudiate his claims about two potential treatments – hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin – but gave public support to the vaccination program.
“I agreed to support the government’s vaccine rollout, which has been endorsed by medical experts,” he said.
“I have always sought to support the success of our nation’s public health response during the pandemic.
Nationals MP and former resources minister Matt Canavan spoke up for Mr Kelly, saying “the best way to lose a debate is to kill a debate” and the backbencher’s views should be debated.
“I think we need more Craig Kellys willing to say unpopular things because it is only by challenging ideas that we get better ideas,” Senator Canavan said.
Australian health authorities do not recommend hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin for COVID-19 but Newcastle University emeritus professor Robert Clancy, a respected immunologist, says studies have shown they are effective and safe, although not a replacement for vaccines.
Mr Kelly made it clear early on Wednesday that he did not oppose vaccination and would make a decision about the COVID-19 vaccines after a consultation with his local doctor.
“I’m absolutely not an anti-vaxxer. I’ve had my photograph taken with my local doctor, I’ve had my photograph taken with my local chemist having a flu vaccination shot,” he said.
While Mr Kelly’s claims about COVID-19 drugs have been disputed for months, the politics escalated on Wednesday morning when Ms Plibersek confronted him in the press gallery corridor.
“My mum lives in your electorate and I don’t want her exposed to people who are not going to be vaccinated because of these crazy conspiracy theories that you’re spreading,” Ms Plibersek told him.
Mr Kelly then held a press conference in which he confirmed the Prime Minister had phoned him the day before, but he said the call had not included any criticism of his public statements or his decision to appear on a podcast with celebrity chef Pete Evans, who has been removed from Facebook for spreading misinformation about COVID-19.
Those comments contradicted a media report the night before, apparently sourced from within the government, that Mr Morrison had given him a “dressing down” over the phone.
With Mr Kelly’s comments being aired live on news programs on Wednesday morning, Mr Morrison called the backbencher into his office for a face-to-face talk in which the Prime Minister said he could not support the backbencher’s views or actions.
Mr Morrison followed this with his statement in Parliament rejecting Mr Kelly’s views.
Start your day informed
Our Morning Edition newsletter is a curated guide to the most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up to The Sydney Morning Herald’s newsletter here, The Age’s here, Brisbane Times’ here, and WAtoday’s here.
Most Viewed in Politics
Source: Read Full Article